Why the Best Expert Doesn't Always Win the Client

‍

You would think that becoming more experienced at what you do would make attracting clients easier.

‍

You know more. You've worked with more people. You've encountered more situations. You've developed judgement that only comes from seeing what works, what doesn't and all the nuances in between.

‍

Yet something strange can happen along the way.

‍

The deeper your expertise becomes, the harder it can become to explain why that expertise matters.

‍

And that can leave brilliant, experienced experts watching people with seemingly less experience attract clients more easily and wondering: What am I missing?

‍

The answer may not be that you need more expertise, more credentials or even more visibility.

‍

You may need to make the value of the expertise you already have easier for the right people to understand.

‍

That's what we'll explore in this episode. And I'll share the simple fix that you can use today that could change everything and ensure you can start attracting and helping more of the right people.

‍

“People don't choose the best expert, they choose the one whose value they understand best.” - Melitta Campbell

‍

‍

Prefer to WATCH?

‍

‍

‍

Why can expertise become harder to explain?

When you're relatively new to something, the answer to a problem can look quite straightforward.

As your experience grows, you start seeing all the variables.

You recognise the exceptions. You understand why something that works brilliantly in one situation could be completely wrong in another. You see connections your client can't yet see and recognise subtle differences that can have significant consequences.

So your answer increasingly becomes:

“It depends.”

Not because you don't know the answer.

Sometimes, “it depends” is the answer of someone who knows too much to pretend there is only one answer.

That doesn't mean someone offering a simpler or narrower solution is a worse expert. Their approach may be exactly right for the person it fits.

The challenge is helping your right client understand which approach fits them.

And that's a communication challenge.

‍

“Sometimes it depends is the answer of someone who knows too much to pretend that there is only one answer.” - Melitta Campbell

‍

Why is a simpler solution sometimes easier to choose?

Imagine a business owner who isn't attracting enough clients.

From where they're standing, the problem might look like this:

“I need more clients, so I need to get better at LinkedIn.”

Perhaps they conclude they need to post more, or find someone who can give them a LinkedIn system for attracting clients.

That's an easy connection to make:

Problem → solution.

An experienced marketing strategist may see something very different.

Who are the right clients? Is the offer right? Is the positioning clear? Does the message communicate the value? Is LinkedIn even the right channel? What are this person's strengths? How do they naturally like to work? What is happening elsewhere in the client journey?

There may be ten questions worth answering before deciding that LinkedIn is the answer.

But here's the important part: the potential client doesn't yet see those ten questions.

They understand their problem from where they are today.

That means a simpler solution can sometimes fit their current understanding of the problem better than a more sophisticated one.

The answer isn't to tell everyone how much cleverer or more experienced you are.

It's to make it easier for the right client to understand why the depth of your approach matters to their situation.

‍

Your experience isn't the value

I've worked in marketing and communications for more than 30 years.

On its own, that fact doesn't tell you very much about why you should work with me.

You might hear “30 years” and think:

“She must have seen almost everything.”

Or you could just as easily wonder:

“Is she still using marketing strategies from the 1990s?”

I can't assume you'll interpret my experience in the way I hope you will.

The useful question isn't:

How many years of experience do I have?

It's:

What does that experience enable me to do for you?

Over those years, I've seen marketing and communications play out across very different organisations, sectors, countries, budgets, teams and situations.

What that experience has taught me is that there isn't one strategy everybody needs to squeeze themselves into.

Instead, I can look at the person, their business, vision, strengths, values, expertise, dream clients, message and circumstances, and use my judgement to help find an approach that fits.

Then we can test it, learn and adapt.

That's where the value sits.

Your experience isn't valuable simply because it took you years to acquire.

It's valuable because of what those years enable you to do for someone now.

‍

“Your experience isn't valuable because you have built it over x number of years. It's valuable because of how that experience enables you to help people now.” - Melitta Campbell

‍

What value has become invisible to you?

There's another problem that comes with experience.

The things you've become very good at can start to feel completely normal.

You spot the real problem quickly.

You instinctively ask a question that changes the conversation.

You recognise a pattern.

You know which details matter and which don't.

You anticipate a problem before it happens, avoid a dead end, adapt something to the person in front of you or recognise when the textbook answer isn't appropriate.

Perhaps you can produce excellent work quickly because you're no longer wasting time exploring routes that experience has taught you won't work.

None of this feels remarkable from inside your own expertise.

It's simply how you work.

But it may be extremely valuable to your client.

So ask yourself:

What can I do now that feels almost effortless to me, but is actually the result of years of accumulated experience?

What do you see faster?

Which questions do you instinctively know to ask?

Which mistakes can you help someone avoid?

What has become obvious to you that isn't obvious to your client?

This is part of recognising your True Value. Expertise can become invisible through familiarity, yet those patterns, perspectives and capabilities may be precisely what makes your work distinctive and valuable.

But recognising them yourself is only the first step.

Your client still needs to understand why they should care.

‍

"Don't just tell clients how experienced you are. Help them understand what your experience makes possible for them." - Melitta Campbell

‍

Turn your expertise into value with two words

One of the simplest ways to make that connection is to take something you routinely say about your expertise and add two words:

“Which means…”

For example:

I have more than 30 years' experience in marketing.

Which means I've seen a huge variety of approaches work – and fail – in very different situations.

Which means I don't need to squeeze your business into one predetermined marketing strategy.

Which means we can work out what fits you, your strengths, your business and the clients you most want to attract – and adapt it as we learn.

We're no longer talking only about a fact about me.

We're getting closer to the question the client is actually asking:

“What's in this for me?”

You may need to ask “which means?” several times before you reach the answer.

Try it with your years of experience, qualifications, methodology, specialist knowledge, sectors you've worked in, unusual combination of skills or something distinctive about the way you work.

Keep asking:

Which means what for my client?

Then go further:

What does this enable me to see, do, avoid, adapt or achieve that someone without this experience might find harder?

And finally:

Why would my right client care?

Don't stop because you've produced a more sophisticated-sounding description of yourself.

Keep going until you reach something that makes the right person think:

“Ah. That would make a difference to me.”

That's when expertise starts becoming value they can recognise.

‍

You don't need to dumb down your expertise

If you've spent years perfecting your craft, the answer isn't to make your expertise less sophisticated.

And it certainly isn't to diminish what you know.

You need to make the value of that expertise easier to understand.

Your clients don't need to understand everything you know before they're ready to take the next step with you. They need to understand enough to recognise what you could make possible for them and why that matters in the situation they're facing today.

Over time, you can help them understand the deeper context and nuance.

But first, you need to meet them where they are.

Because people don't choose the best expert. They choose the one whose value they understand best.

So instead of asking:

“How can I show people how much I know?”

try asking:

“How can I make it easier for the right people to understand what everything I know makes possible for them?”

When you do that, you're no longer asking potential clients simply to trust that you're an expert because of your years of experience, qualifications or credentials.

You're helping them recognise for themselves why you could be the obvious choice for them.

‍

"Your expertise doesn't need to become less sophisticated. Its value needs to become easier to understand." - Melitta Campbell

‍

Your Value Whispering challenge

Choose one thing you currently use as evidence of your expertise.

Write it down and keep asking:

“Which means…?”

Follow the thread until you reach the meaningful difference it makes for your right client.

You may find there is far more value hiding inside something you've been taking for granted than you realised.

‍

Listen Next

Continue with Episode 315 — Why Brilliant Experts Struggle to Attract Clients (and Why It's Probably Not for the Reason You Think).

That episode explores the Value Recognition Problem: why something that appears to be a marketing or visibility problem may actually begin with people not recognising enough of your value.

Together, the two episodes explore both sides of the challenge: recognising that your value isn't being seen clearly enough, and then making the depth of your expertise easier for the right people to understand.

‍

‍

About Your Host, Melitta Campbell

Melitta Campbell is the creator of the Value Whispering® methodology, a 3x bestselling author, TEDx speaker and an award-winning communications and marketing expert with more than 30 years' experience helping organisations, leaders and service-based experts communicate their value more clearly.

Through her books, keynote talks, coaching and this podcast, she challenges conventional marketing wisdom and helps experts become the obvious choice through smarter - not louder - marketing.

Her work is built on one simple belief:

‍People don't choose the best expert.
They choose the one whose value they understand best.

‍

Learn more about working with Melitta here
‍

Connect with Melitta

Linkedin      Substack     YouTube  

‍

‍

‍

‍

> More Podcast Episodes

‍